Quality Control: Don’t Accept Inferior Stud Installation

Terrible Stud Job

The best studded tires on the market today utilize advanced stud designs that are proprietary to their particular manufacturer, and are installed at the factory by machines to ensure perfect installation.  While there are many options for these advanced winter tires on the European market, the North American market is very limited, with only the Nokian Hakkapeliita, Gislaved Nord Frost, and Pirelli Ice Zero available; in a limited range of sizes.

Nokian Hakka 8 Stud Close UpFactory Installed Nokian Hakka Stud – Perfect Every Time

For many studded tire users – especially those with trucks or large SUVs – the availability of modern studded winter tires is poor, or they are simply prohibitively expensive.  Those drivers must turn to having TSMI studs installed by hand into a studdable winter tire, using a stud gun.

TSMI studs are a simple design from the 1960s.  They are inferior in performance and durability to modern stud designs and, in steel-bodied form, also cause more damage to the roads due to their extra weight.

TSMI StudsTSMI Studs

different_std_524a6731cf4a0Examples of Modern European Stud Designs

However, aluminum-bodied TSMI studs will not cause excessive road damage, and if installed properly they can provide adequate performance and service life.  Unfortunately, this is not always the case.  In fact, it is quite common to receive poorly-studded tires from tire shops and online distributors, so be careful who you select to stud your tires.  The installers often don’t have the experience or knowledge to do a proper job, or simply don’t care.  Much of that apathy may be due to the job itself.  Studding tires is a tedious, monotonous job that can become physically uncomfortable by the end of even a single set of tires.  It is certainly a job that is best performed by robots and machines.

Evaluating the Studs

When you first receive your freshly studded tires, examine them very thoroughly, because this is your only chance to make corrections or refuse the product.  Do not accept an inadequate job, as you will be unhappy with your tire performance and stud life for years to follow.  Tires can not be re-studded once in use unless new holes are drilled, and custom studding requires more work and a higher level of competence than using factory-supplied stud holes, assuming there is even enough un-siped tread block area to reliably place new stud holes.

With a proper stud installation, the stud base – the metal housing surrounding the center pin – should be approximately level with the surface of the tire tread.  Up to 1/32″ of variation is allowable.

Tire Rack Stud InsertionStud Depth

If the stud is inserted too deep or the stud used is too short for the hole, it will be ineffective until enough rubber wears away to expose the carbide tip.  If stud insertion is too shallow or the stud is too long for the hole, it will protrude excessively, increasing tire noise and causing rapid wear of both stud and road until the stud fails prematurely, well before the usable winter tire life is exceeded.  Longer studs will often be used for ice racing but are inappropriate for paved roads.  The length of the carbide pin is 5.2 mm regardless of TSMI size, so excessive stud length simply exposes more of the pin, which is too delicate without the support of its metal jacket to handle the forces of high-grip surfaces.

See the following images, courtesy of Tire Rack, for examples of stud insertion depths:

Good Install 2Good Installation

Studs Too Deep 2

Stud Too Short or Installed too Deep

Studs Too Shallow 2Studs Too Long or Installed too Shallow

SSTC Recommended Installers

SSTC members have received good studding jobs from the following tire shops or distributors:

Bell Tire Regina

Quality Tire Regina

PMC Tire Online

Tire Rack Online

Value Tire Regina

Value Tire Saskatoon

SSTC members have received poor studding jobs from the following tire shops or distributors:

Canadian Tire Saskatoon Preston Crossing

Discount Tire Online

3 Comments

Filed under Editorials

3 Responses to Quality Control: Don’t Accept Inferior Stud Installation

  1. Barry triestman

    Just got a set of goodyear ultra grip ice 275 70 18 with studs installed the depth of the
    studs was very inconsistent so they are going back to tire rack. How do I know it the correct stud type are being installed when i get the replacement pair? This is the second set of studded tires I have put on my 2011 chevy 3500 with an arctic fox 990 truck camper. They where firestone winter force lt same size. I did not inspect those before they where installed and many studs where gone after the first season and I am wondering if that was due to improper installation, incorrect stud type, poor tire selection or just a lot of weight. I have tried to contact both goodyear and tirerack but both are clueless as anything about studs to my horror

    • rpn453

      I’m sorry to hear about your poor experience with Tire Rack. Hopefully they get it right for you. Let us know what happened.

      Different stud sizes can have different colors. But the difference may not be obvious, so often the only way you could know for sure whether the proper size stud is used is to remove and measure one.

      https://brunowessel.com/tire-studs/car-light-truck-studs/

      But you will not be able to reinstall it without a stud gun, so best to trust the installer. If they get the insertion depth consistent and correct, it’s almost certain the stud is the correct size. You’d have to be a tire studding wizard to do a good job with the incorrect size!

      I suspect that the studs in the Firestones were also incorrectly installed. It’s a common problem. I have friends who have run studded Winterforces on trucks for many years without issue, and friends who have run studded tires on 2500 and 3500 trucks for years without issue, so I doubt that either the tires or the weight are the issue. Although, I don’t personally know anyone who has run studded Winterforces on a HD truck, so I suppose I can’t say for sure.

  2. Pingback: Best 10ply AT's for snow and ice? - Page 6 - Chevy and GMC Duramax Diesel Forum

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.